It’s Not About Mika & Joe

The Power a Free Press 

Elijah Parish Lovejoy was a Presbyterian minister in St. Louis, Missouri, who worked as an editor at the St, Louis Observer where he wrote editorials opposing slavery.

After anti-abolitionists destroyed his press for the third time, Lovejoy moved across the river to Alton, Illinois, and started another abolitionist paper.  In 1837, a pro-slavery mob attacked the warehouse where he had set up his fourth printing press. Lovejoy was shot and died on the spot.

I tell Lovejoy’s story as a reminder of the importance of freedom of the press established by the First Amendment and as a witness to the forces that are always at work to undermine or destroy it.

It’s Not About Mika & Joe 

I also tell that story to say that there is more at stake in the President’s Twitter tirade against “Morning Joe” and his continuing attacks on the “media” than morning headlines or cheering crowds.

Anyone who was surprised by Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough’s comments about the President simply hasn’t been paying attention.  They are who they are — cable news commentators who join a long line of journalists, cartoonists, and editors who have debated, criticized, mocked, or pointed to the duplicity of our leaders throughout our history.  A free press is not about whether we agree or disagree, but about the freedom to speak, write, debate, and argue with and about our leaders.

Anyone who was surprised by Donald Trump’s visceral, vulgar, sexist attack on Mika hasn’t been paying attention either.  This is who he is.  Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the current myth-spinner in the White House Press Room, told the truth when she said that the American people “knew what they were getting when they voted for Donald Trump.”  (She lied when she said the President had never in “any form or fashion” encouraged violence.  Just watch the campaign rally tapes.)  The President is what he has consistently demonstrated himself to be: thin-skinned, impulsive, mean-spirited, and perhaps sleep-deprived.  (I’ve had crazy thoughts at 3:00 AM, too, but I try go back to sleep!)

But Donald Trump is the President of the United States and that makes all the difference.  There is a “double standard.”  We need our President to rise above either the praise or the critique of TV commentators.  In fact, these continual attacks on the press are undermining the freedoms we celebrate on the 4th of July.

“A Nation Conceived in Liberty…” 

As I’ve reflected on the meaning of this day, I’ve realized that it is my respect for the values and vision enshrined in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Bill 19511086_10212095438212834_2575473102798889724_nof Rights, and the Gettysburg Address that inspires my patriotism and causes my concern.

I respect the Presidency too highly to respect a President who drags the office into the fake world of professional wrestling.

I respect the flag “and the republic for which it stands” too highly to be passive when our President diminishes respect for our nation around the world.

I respect the Christian faith too highly to allow it be to coopted by a leader whose behavior is a consistent contradiction of everything the New Testament says about what it looks like to be a follower of Christ.

I respect freedom of religion (all religions) too highly to allow the church to be wedded to any political party.  (When the church and political power go to bed together, the church becomes an abused spouse.)

I respect those who have given their lives in the service of their country too highly to allow their sacrifice to be tarnished by crass nationalism that masquerades as patriotism.

It’s About Us! 

In the end, “the present crisis” (to borrow James Russel Lowell’s phrase) is not about Mika and Joe, and it’s not entirely about the President.  It’s about us — about who we are.  It’s about how we choose to live into the yet-to-be-fulfilled vision of “liberty and justice for all.” It’s about how we practice the freedoms enunciated in the Bill of Rights. It’s about how we commit ourselves “to form a more perfect union.”  It’s about the way we choose to treat the people who disagree with us.  For those who claim to be Christian, it’s about how we shape our behavior into the likeness of Jesus.

After the fireworks are over, may this day remind us of who we are called to be. And  may we “be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us–that we here highly resolve…that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom–and that government  of the people, by the people and for the people shall not perish from the earth.” 

Grace and peace,



It’s particularly about us as men.  I’ve had it with people calling on the women in Congress and in the White House to speak out against the President’s vulgar attacks on women.  We men are the ones who bear the responsibility for the way women are treated in this culture.  Particularly white men like me who have unintentionally benefited from the coincidence that we were born white and male in a culture that historically has been infected with white prejudice to any person of any color or ethnic minority and which continues to been infected by an inbred bias in favor of male leadership.







Categories Uncategorized

12 thoughts on “It’s Not About Mika & Joe

  1. Bernard Lieving July 4, 2017 — 7:44 pm

    Jim Great job with this one

    There seems to be a division in my copy as several paragraphs appear after your ending. Maybe my crazy phone.

    Sent from my iPhone


  2. Thanks! You were too quick! After posting I realized I had not cut away some extra stuff in the draft and I had to go back in to edit it out. Cheers on your retirement!

  3. Carolyn Linder July 4, 2017 — 9:01 pm

    I do so appreciate your posts. They reflect how I think and feel. Thank you so much. Carolyn

    Sent from my iPhone


  4. John, Judie Thomas July 4, 2017 — 11:43 pm

    Thank you, Jim, for your voice which speaks for so many of us!

  5. CARMEN CUNNINGHAM July 5, 2017 — 12:54 am

    Jim, Bravo! Peace, Carmen

  6. M.L. Brinkman July 5, 2017 — 1:10 am

    I fully support your view, Jim.

    BTW, I hope that you noticed that the blog became disjointed at the end.

    1. Thanks for the affirmation. The disjointed stuff at the end was material I had cut from the first draft and didn’t realize was still down on the page when I hit “Publish.” Sometimes the computer is faster than I am! 🙂

      1. Jim… so glad you write in the evening instead of 3:00 in the morning


  7. Don’t know when you wrote this yesterday, but I’m glad you did. Thank you both for a lovely day; it was good to spend a few hours together, and we enjoyed the drive in both directions. I am a fireworks nut, and Charley stoically watches with me every year A Capitol Fourth; two years I actually watched the DC fireworks in DC–once with Talley and once with Dora [Talley may have been with Dora and me, but I’m not sure]; Dora didn’t give a flip about fireworks, but she was that kind of friend. I will miss her forever and especially remember her on the 4th. Now we have our lovely visit w/ the Harnishes and friends to add to those memories. Love, Linda

    Sent from my iPad


  8. I had been working on the blog post for a couple days, but finished after you left. In fact, some material that I thought I had edited out (to keep it shorter) still appeared on the bottom of the post. I’m still learning how to use the technology! Great to be with you! We watched DC, too, then the channel showing NYC, which was pretty amazing. In spite of the shape the country is in right now, we still have lots of good things to celebrate! That includes our friendship with you!

  9. Well said. Would you consider putting this blog in the form of a letter to the editor? It needs wider dissemination. Thanks. Bob

  10. Brilliant post…well written. Wish this could be re-printed in the major newspapers and magazines across our country.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close