A Birthright for a Mess of Politics

A Con Artist of Biblical Proportion

It’s hard to beat Frederick Buechner’s description of Jacob.

Jacob was, among other things, a crook…Jacob was never satisfied. He wanted the moon, and if he’d ever managed to bilk heaven out of that, he would have been back the next morning for the stars to go with it. 

It was a turning point in scripture when Esau, Jacob’s first-born, fraternal twin brother, came in from working in the field and found Jacob mixing up a batch of beef stew. Esau was starving and asked Jacob to serve up a dish of it.  Jacob said, “Let’s make a deal.  I’ll trade you some stew for your birthright.” Without giving it much thought, Esau said, “I’m starving! What good is a birthright if I’m dead?” Esau enjoyed the stew but later regretted what he traded for it.  (Genesis 25:29-31)

Some older translations referred to Jacob’s stew as “a mess of pottage” which became a metaphor for “something immediately attractive but of little value taken foolishly and carelessly in exchange for something more distant and perhaps less tangible but immensely more valuable.”

A Mess of White House Pottage  

I remembered the bargain between Jacob and Esau when I read the reports of the  “evangelical” leaders who went to dinner at the White House a few weeks ago.  That’s big deal.  I remember how important you feel when you walk into the Oval Office and get a picture taken with the President.  White-House-Dinner-for-Evangelicals-800x430It’s no small thing to be invited to dinner with the President, Vice-President and First Lady.

Sadly, as Esau learned, it doesn’t come cheap.  In his remarks, the President was perfectly clear that they were there for what they are doing for him.  There isn’t space in the East Room for any Nathan-like prophet who would hold the President accountable for his behavior. (2 Samuel 12:1-17)

My Evangelical Birthright

I grew up on the evangelical branch of the Methodist family tree.  I was diapered on church pews where evangelical preachers proclaimed an evangelical gospel and challenged me to live an evangelically-defined Christian life.  Along with teaching me to sing hymns, pray and listen for the Spirit, they taught me the meaning of honesty, sexual morality, respect, and compassion for others. My evangelical forbearers placed a high value on American democracy and opposed anything that looked like authoritarian or dictatorial rule.

It’s because of my evangelical birthright that I made my earliest commitments to follow Christ, started tithing my income, heard God’s call to ministry, and have been faithful to the way the United Methodist Book of Discipline defines sexual morality as “celibacy in singleness and fidelity in marriage.”

Jacob’s Bargain

I still consider myself to be “evangelical” in the original sense of the word.  But as hungry for political power as Esau was for supper, today’s “evangelicals” have made a strange bargain with their birthright.

  • They traded their commitment to truth for a President who lies with such ease that it’s hard for fact checkers to keep up with him.
  • They traded their commitment to sexuality morality for a President who trades wives as if they were used cars, described himself as a sexual predator, and whose attorney openly acknowledged that he paid a porn star for her silence.
  • They traded biblical compassion for immigrants and children for an immigration policy that separates children from their parents.
  • They traded “Give me your tired, your poor…” for “Build a wall!”
  • They traded their commitment to democracy for cozy friendships with dictators.

There is a sad history of this kind of bargain. Whenever the church has gotten too close to political power, it has always ended up being the loser.  Don’t forget the way the church in Germany sold its birthright to Hitler.

The True Birthright 

By contrast, here’s the way Martin Luther King, Jr., described the church’s relationship with political power in his book, The Strength to Love. We need to be reminded of his message, regardless of which party holds the keys to the White House.

The church must be reminded that it is not the master or the servant of the state, but rather the conscience of the state. It must be the guide and the critic of the state, and never its tool. If the church does not recapture its prophetic zeal, it will become an irrelevant social club without moral or spiritual authority…But if the church will free itself from the shackles of a deadening status quo, and, recovering its great historic mission, will speak and act fearlessly and insistently in terms of justice and peace, it will enkindle the imagination of [humankind] and fire the souls of [people], imbuing them with a glowing and ardent love for truth, justice, and peace. (Strength to Love, 1963)

I hope my “evangelical” brothers and sisters enjoyed dinner at the White House as much as Esau enjoyed Jacob’s stew, because like Esau, all of us who represent the Christian faith will pay a high price for it.

Grace and peace,







Categories Uncategorized

6 thoughts on “A Birthright for a Mess of Politics

  1. Thanks for a good word, Jim. I see parallels in another story: the 850 false prophets who ate at Jezabel’s table (1 Kings18:19). As I am sure you know, Walter Brueggemann has written extensively on the Bible’s denouncement of imperialism, which sadly is always a collusion of political and religious leaders. As youbnote, we are seeing it playing out in spades today.

  2. Thanks for your message, Jim. I just finished reading “Unhinged” by Omarosa Manigault Newman. She describes the President as lacking empathy and narcissistic — which means “extremely self-centered with an exaggerated sense of self-importance; marked by or characteristic of excessive admiration of or infatuation with oneself.”

  3. Another gem from Jim. I find myself in high company on this web site. We appreciate Jim so much that we are using one of his books as our study guide with our small group at Beymer Methodist. And it is good to see Archie Buie’s name as we remember Archie from St. John’s in Winter Haven. Best wishes to you both. Bob Williams

  4. Greetings Moruti!
    Your words are both timely and wise.
    As a person fortunate to finally see the birth of democracy in South Africa, I fully identify with your words with regards to the church and politics.
    Without the “rubber stamp” provided by the Afrikaans church for the evil of apartheid, I have every reason to believe it would not have been accepted by the majority of white South Africans.
    We live in dangerous times!

  5. Jim, after reading your remark about the minister workshop and the weather, I thought about the state of Methodist preaching. This made think that the Church needs someone like you (you) teaching young ministers at one of the seminaries. So many people know you that all you would to do is mention your interest and you would be hired. Martha might not mind moving back to Asbury. Pray about it.

    1. David: I appreciate your affirmation and new job opportunity! I (and this goes for my wife!) am not interested in another full-time job, but I get to help preachers grow in their preaching through the Institute of Preaching (https://divinity.duke.edu/events/institute-preaching). It’s a joint program with Duke Divinity School, the Western North Carolina and Florida Conferences. We’re in our 12th year of offering it and have actually seem some real improvement in preachers who participate in it. Thanks for the encouragement!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close